Staff Augmentation vs Outsourcing: Which Option Should You Choose?

In today’s world, staying competitive is essential to business success. To face the complexities of this new demanding market, and stay atop of the game, by remaining innovative and successfully meeting deadlines, it becomes a great option to optimize the in-house workforce.

These goals can be achieved by implementing engagement models such as staff augmentation and outsourcing. But which one is the right fit for your company? This is a critical decision that can significantly impact your operational efficiency, so keep on reading this article to find out all you need to know about staff augmentation and outsourcing, and choose the option that is right for your business.

What is Staff Augmentation and Outsourcing?

Staff augmentation and outsourcing are two strategic approaches employed to optimize business operations. These models are particularly helpful in the realms of project management, IT services, and other specialized fields. To get a clear idea about what each of these models is about, we need to take a closer look at them.

Staff augmentation. This is a flexible strategy that allows companies to hire skilled and top-level talent on an as-needed basis. This also means a business does not have to deal with the long-term commitment of a full-time employee, while being able to remain competitive and to meet their projects’ needs and deadlines effectively. 

Outsourcing. This is a strategy that makes it possible for companies to delegate some of their business processes or services to an external agency or third-party service provider. This model reduces costs, while making it possible for high-skilled workers to take care of delegated tasks. These tasks could range from customer service and accounting to IT services and digital marketing.

What is important to know is that both, staff augmentation and outsourcing, provide businesses with the flexibility and scalability they need to adapt to changing market dynamics and business needs.

Types of Staff Augmentation and Outsourcing

Each approach caters to different needs, whether it’s filling an immediate skill gap or entrusting entire business processes to specialized providers. Understanding these options can help tailor your approach to align with your company’s unique objectives and challenges. Let’s see the principal types of staff augmentation and outsourcing:

Type	Staff Augmentation	Outsourcing
Traditional Staff Augmentation	Bringing in individual contractors or temporary employees to work on-site or remotely.	Traditional outsourcing involves handing over a complete function or project to an external vendor for them to manage end-to-end.
Commodity Staff Augmentation	Supplying personnel for non-specialized tasks where the main requirement is to fill a seat and perform basic functions.	Offshore Outsourcing – Engaging with vendors in other countries to leverage cost advantages for large-scale operations.
Skill-based Staff Augmentation	Sourcing highly skilled or specialized professionals for specific projects or tasks, often in areas like IT or engineering.	Managed Services Outsourcing – A service provider manages and delivers services defined by the client, often with a commitment to performance metrics.
Long-term Staff Augmentation	Engaging contractors for extended periods, providing the benefits of a stable workforce without the commitments of full-time employment.	Business Process Outsourcing (BPO) – Outsourcing an entire business process, such as customer service, accounting, or HR, to a third party.
Strategic Staff Augmentation	Leveraging temporary expert-level professionals to guide strategy or manage major initiatives.	Knowledge Process Outsourcing (KPO) – Delegating tasks that require advanced analytical and specialized skills, such as research, development, or financial analysis.
On-demand Staff Augmentation	Accessing an on-call workforce that can be rapidly deployed as needs arise, often facilitated by staffing platforms.	Cloud Outsourcing – Utilizing cloud services providers for IT resources, platforms, or infrastructure, reducing the need for in-house IT management.
SOW (Statement of Work) Based Staff Augmentation	Contracting external personnel based on deliverables or milestones, which is common in consulting or project-based engagements.	IT Outsourcing – Outsourcing of IT services including software development, maintenance, and support to a third-party vendor.

Benefits of Staff Augmentation

Improved flexibility. Staff augmentation makes it possible for businesses to scale their team up or down on their specific workload needs. This also means companies do not have to deal with the expenses of full-time employees, such as administrative duties.

Access to specialized skills. Staff augmentation makes it possible for businesses to get in touch with specialized workers to complement or fill their in-house team. The added staff members work directly with the in-house team and are under the direct oversight of managers. 

Cost-effectiveness. The staff augmentation model not only allows you to fill in gaps of knowledge or skill within the in-house team, but it also makes it a cost-effective solution to the problem. These specialized workers tend to be hired on a seasonal, or project-to-project basis, which reduces administrative costs related to hiring and training new employees.

Benefits of Outsourcing

Cost savings. Outsourcing is a good option to reduce costs, as the burden relies on the vendor after the contracts have been signed. Training, managing and delivering the final product is part of the vendor’s contractual obligations.

Focus on core competencies. By outsourcing talent, and delegating tasks to those workers, it becomes easier to free up time and to focus on other core aspects of the business.

Access to a global talent pool. Outsourcing makes it possible to have access to highly skilled workers without being bound to local talent. In the era of remote work, talented professionals become available to contribute to your business growth easily.

Differences Between Staff Augmentation and Outsourcing

Staff augmentation and outsourcing are two key business strategies used to meet operational and project-based needs. Still, it is important to understand that both approaches are fundamentally different in execution.

Criteria	Staff Augmentation	Outsourcing
Talent Management	Businesses manage augmented staff alongside in-house employees.	Vendor manages all aspects of the outsourced workforce.
Skill Gaps	Used to fill specific skill gaps temporarily.	Used to outsource entire processes or operations beyond immediate skill gaps.
Cost Structure	Pay for services on a temporary or as-needed basis.	Potential long-term cost savings with a fixed contract for outsourced services.
Operational Control	Businesses maintain direct control over work.	Control lies with the vendor who manages the outsourced tasks.

On the one hand, staff augmentation is a strategy that brings on board highly skilled talent and specialized temporary employees to complement the existing in-house workforce. This model allows businesses to adapt to the fluctuating demand of today’s market, and avoid overhead costs associated with full-time employees. This model is an excellent solution for businesses that need to fill skill gaps or need additional manpower for short-term projects.

On the other hand, outsourcing involves delegating business processes or projects, as required, to an external agency or third-party provider. The vendor has the contractual obligation of training and managing the skilled workers who will carry on the delegated tasks. In turn, this allows businesses to focus on their core competencies while leaving non-core tasks to experts in their respective fields. 

When is it better to choose Staff Augmentation?

Choosing staff augmentation can be a game changer in multiple scenarios, but it can be especially useful when dealing with a temporary workload increase or embarking on a short-term project. With staff augmentation you will be able to oversight and have control over the work, as the dedicated team of skilled workers will use the company’s systems, making it easier for them to also co-work with the existing in-house team.

Moreover, staff augmentation might be the preferred choice when your company is trying to minimize costs associated with maintaining permanent employees. Staff augmentation is the perfect option that provides extra hands and expertise without the long-term commitment of hiring full-time staff.

When is it better to choose Outsourcing?

Deciding to go for the outsourcing service option largely depends on the specific needs and circumstances of your business. It might be convenient to look into outsourcing when your business is expanding, or when the cost of managing certain operations in-house exceeds the cost of outsourcing. Also, it might be convenient to consider outsourcing when your team has a gap to fill, whether it will be in skill or workforce to face a surge in workload.

Additionally, outsourcing is an excellent choice when businesses aim to focus more on their core competencies, as delegating tasks will free up time to take care of other business aspects. Moreover, outsourcing allows a business to be levered of the responsibilities of training and managing workers. By hiring a vendor, you are assured that the product of the delegated tasks is high quality and that they are delivered on time.

When to Choose Staff Augmentation or Outsourcing

Scenario	Staff Augmentation	Outsourcing
Short-term Needs	Ideal for temporary workload increase or specific short-term projects.	Less suitable due to potential for longer-term engagement.
Cost of Permanent Employees	To minimize costs associated with maintaining a full-time workforce.	When managing in-house operations becomes more expensive than outsourcing.
Control Over Work	When oversight and direct control of the work is necessary.	When businesses want to offload the management of certain tasks.
Skill/Workforce Gap	To fill specific skill or workforce gaps temporarily.	To permanently fill a gap or when specialized expertise is needed.

Cost Comparison: Staff Augmentation vs Outsourcing

When comparing the costs of staff augmentation and outsourcing, it’s crucial to consider several key factors that relate to the specific business goals and endeavors. It is necessary to evaluate both models and identify their benefits to see which one better suits you and your team’s needs.

When choosing staff augmentation, for example, a business may want to take into account that this model is good on a temporary, project-by-project basis. This approach can be highly cost-effective, as it eliminates the need for long-term contracts and commitments while allowing you to get in touch with top-level professionals to work in-house. Companies control their operational costs, as they only pay for the services they need when they need them. 

On the other hand, when choosing outsourcing, you will be contracting an external agency to take over certain business tasks, projects, or operations. This model is better suited for long-term projects or needs, leading to significant cost savings in terms of infrastructure, technology, and operational costs. The outsourcing provider takes care of the aforementioned aspects. 

In any case, when looking to hire external workers, businesses should carefully consider the specific needs that need to be covered, and the specifics of the project in hand, such as duration and budget, before deciding which approach to take.

Conclusion

The world is rapidly changing, and along with it is how we carry out different tasks and handle business projects. Therefore, businesses must adapt to the new demands and the new resources available to stay competitive, innovative, and at the top of their game.

When it comes to choosing between staff augmentation and outsourcing, it’s important to understand the unique needs and challenges your business faces, as well as its goals. Both models offer distinct advantages and can be used effectively to streamline operations, optimize resources, and manage costs.  

Get immersed in these new alternatives to make your business grow with the help of Wizards. Get in contact with our team today to take your business to the next level!

FAQs